By Scott Lawson · Branch Manager · October 2, 2024 · Reprinted 8/22/2026
There is plenty of advice floating around the media that is very negative about owning your own home. Almost all of it misses what actually happens once you have owned for a while, and what you miss is powerful.
Most of the negative takes come from a 28-year-old writer at a large news outlet who has never owned a home in their life. The argument is always the same: owning costs so much more than renting. So let us dig into that a bit.
Owning a home carries benefits you simply do not see in the first few months of writing out those checks to your mortgage servicer. They show up over time, and they are quite powerful. They are:
Let us start with appreciation. I have a client in Sonoma County who purchased a property less than a year ago, in November of 2023, for $587,629. Interest rates have dropped since then, and he decided it was a good time to refinance. We needed an appraisal, which we just received, and it came in at $650,000. His original investment was $17,629 (that was the down payment; the seller paid the closing costs) for a whopping $62,371 gain, or a 353.80% return in less than a year.
That is the power of leverage. Your return is measured against the cash you actually put in, not the full price of the home, so a modest move in value turns into an outsized gain on your own money. Leveraged real estate can be one of the best wealth builders available to the public. Try that with Bitcoin.
Next, the interest you pay on the mortgage for your primary residence is tax deductible up to a $750,000 loan amount (please contact your tax advisor for proper guidance). Your mortgage payment has two components, principal and interest. The interest is deductible, and the principal portion pays down your loan. It is you paying yourself, not unlike a forced savings account. Pretty cool when you think about it.
And because your payment is mostly interest in the early years, that write-off is at its largest right at the start, when a new payment tends to sting the most.
Last, the federal government allows a nifty tax benefit when you sell. If you are married and you lived in the property for two of the five years prior to the sale, you may exclude up to $500,000 of the capital gain. Buy for $500,000, sell for $1,000,000, and that half a million is tax exempt. The exclusion is $250,000 if you are single. Again, consult a licensed tax advisor for the details.
People often confuse this with a 1031 exchange, where the proceeds must be rolled into another property for the gain to be tax deferred. That only applies to investment properties, meaning rentals. Careful not to mix the two up.
"Owning a home is, and should be, premium priced versus renting. It costs more, and that is exactly the point."
There you go. A tax benefit while you live in the property, a powerful way to build wealth as you pay your housing expense, and a large potential tax break if you ever decide to sell. Homeownership comes with financial benefits most people never see in the early going, and the media is not doing the public any favors by leaving all of it out. It is not just a matter of comparing monthly checks, renting versus owning.
Owning a home is, and should be, premium priced versus renting. More expensive, yes, and that is the point.
Those who put off owning until it becomes evenly priced with renting are on a fool's errand. Good luck.
One conversation lays out your real down payment, your price range, and the long-term math on owning versus renting. No pressure, no cost.
Prefer to talk now? Call (415) 529-5056 · Open Mon–Sun, 8am–9pm
America's Home Loans Inc. DBA Marin Mortgage Brokers is a licensed independent mortgage brokerage (company NMLS #231434, CA DRE #01524386). Scott Lawson serves as Branch Manager (individual NMLS #312312, CA DRE #01895185). This page is for educational purposes only and is not a commitment to lend, nor is it tax or legal advice. Tax rules and benefits depend on your individual circumstances; consult a licensed tax professional regarding your situation. All loans are subject to credit approval, income and asset verification, property appraisal, and underwriting review. Program guidelines and terms are subject to change without notice. Not all applicants will qualify. Equal Housing Opportunity.